This potential lineup discussion could be heating up for Duke basketball.
The Duke basketball team might have one of the deepest and most balanced rosters in the country — but not even depth can hide the brewing tension at one key position. Two games into the season, it’s becoming clear that Jon Scheyer may soon need to make an important decision at point guard.
The ongoing battle between Caleb Foster and Cayden Boozer has been one of Duke’s biggest early-season storylines. Both have impressed in different ways, but Boozer’s recent play has given fans — and possibly Scheyer — something to think about.
The Case for Caleb Foster
Foster entered the season as the experienced floor general, earning the starting nod in both of Duke’s first two games. His defense has been exceptional, consistently setting the tone with his energy on the perimeter. Through those matchups, Foster has averaged 8.0 points, 3.5 rebounds, and 3.0 assists while shooting 53.8% from the field and 50% from three.
Still, he’s been selective with his offense — attempting only a little over five shots per game — and has preferred to let others carry the scoring load. His steadiness, leadership, and poise are all valuable, but it raises one key question: does Duke need a more aggressive scorer running the show?
The Case for Cayden Boozer
That’s where Boozer comes in. In Duke’s most recent win over Western Carolina, the freshman made the most of his extended minutes after Foster dealt with foul trouble. Boozer logged 14 points, 7 rebounds, 5 assists, and 2 steals in 27 minutes, shooting 50% from the field and showing flashes of what makes him one of the most talented young guards in the country.
While Boozer is still developing his outside shot, his feel for the game and natural passing instincts have stood out. He plays with a poise beyond his years — and his ability to create offense both for himself and others could give Duke’s lineup a new dynamic.
A Decision That Could Shape the Season
If Scheyer decides to shake up the starting five, it wouldn’t be a dramatic overhaul. Both guards would continue to see significant minutes, but giving Boozer the nod could send a message about the direction Duke wants to go — youth, pace, and offensive versatility.
It would also mean the Blue Devils start three freshmen, something that might seem risky early but could pay off in March.
For now, there’s no wrong answer. Foster’s defense and leadership are proven assets, while Boozer’s offensive potential is impossible to ignore. But as the season unfolds and Duke faces tougher competition, that “uncomfortable” conversation about who should be the permanent starter may become unavoidable.
