In the world of professional basketball, longevity is typically celebrated — a sign of greatness, dedication, and resilience. But according to NBA guard Malcolm Brogdon, LeBron James’ historic career longevity might ironically be one of the reasons he faces so much criticism.
Speaking candidly in a recent interview, Brogdon highlighted a unique paradox: LeBron is the first player whose incredible staying power is seemingly used against him.
> “He’s the first player in this game to have longevity that is counted against him, you know? It’s one of his downfalls,” Brogdon said, pulling back the curtain on a reality many fans and analysts have overlooked.
Since entering the league in 2003, LeBron James has maintained a level of performance that’s not just rare — it’s unprecedented. At age 39, he’s still averaging elite numbers, leading his team in crucial moments, and breaking records with what seems like every passing game.
Yet, as Brogdon points out, the more LeBron achieves, the more his critics find ways to diminish it.
“People forget that playing this long at such a high level is nearly impossible. Instead of praising that, they use it to say he’s had ‘more time’ to chase records or championships,” Brogdon explained.
This has become especially apparent in the never-ending GOAT (Greatest of All Time) debate. While Michael Jordan’s shorter, six-title career is often held as the standard, LeBron’s extended career — which now includes four championships, multiple MVPs, and the all-time scoring record — is sometimes downplayed because of its length.
Critics argue he’s “had more chances” or “played in a weaker era longer,” ignoring the fact that maintaining dominance over two decades requires more than talent — it takes discipline, reinvention, and an iron will.
Brogdon’s comments have reignited a conversation that’s long simmered among players and fans alike: Should LeBron be celebrated more for his unmatched career longevity, or has his extended presence in the league unfairly shifted how his greatness is measured?
In the end, Brogdon believes it’s time to flip the narrative.
Longevity should be a pillar of greatness, not a knock against it,” he said. “What LeBron is doing — nobody’s ever done before. That deserves nothing but respect.”
As LeBron continues to defy time, chase more milestones, and inspire the next generation, one thing is clear: his legacy will be defined not just by what he did, but by how long he did it — and how few could ever keep up.
